Mei-ling Lu |
The Potential Impact of the Modern Literal Taiwanese in Latin Alphabet on the Ethnic Identity and Communication Among the Taiwanese People |
--> | Prospects-0 | EDUTECH-T |
UP |
UP |
UP |
UP |
The
Potential Impact of the Modern Literal
Taiwanese
in Latin Alphabet on the Ethnic Identity
and
Communication among the Taiwanese People
by
Mei-ling
Lu, M.S.
School
of Mass Communication and Public Relations
College
of Communication Boston University
September,
1993
Thesis Advisor: Dr. Julia, R. Dobrow, Assistant Professor
_Language is a primary channel of human communication; it is the most
UP |
UP |
UP |
UP |
____This
thesis investigated the potential impact of a modern literal Taiwanese
in
____
Latin alphabet on
the ethnic identity and communication of the Taiwanese
____
people.
____
____The
problems defined and discussed in this thesis were developed through
____
the following statements:
UP |
UP |
UP |
UP |
UP |
1.2-1 Taiwanese and Its Chinese Writing
____All
dialects spoken in China or other geographical regions with population
____
of Chinese
descendants are generally referred as "Chinese." But
the term
____
"Chinese" is anumbrella
designation for at least eight present-day varieties of
____
mutually unintelligiblelanguages;
this situation is parallel to the various languages
____
that make up the Romancegroup
of languages (DeFrancis, 1989, P.94). And just
____
as these varieties
of speech are mutually unintelligible, so are
the varieties of
____
written language based
on them (DeFrancis,1989, p.95). It is
a myth that
____
Chinese characters
cut across boundaries of speech; the reality of Chinese
writing
____
is that the characters
have been created by speakers of many differentvarieties of
____
dialects and often
reflect the peculiarities of their speech (DeFrancis, 1989,p.95).
____
Therefore, even though
the Mandarin dialect has been the official language of
____
both Taiwan and China
in the basis of writing, it takes more efforts for a
____
non-native speaker
of Mandarin, such as a Cantonese, to learn to read
and write
____
in the national standard
than it does for a Spaniard to learn to read and write
____
French (DeFrancis
1984a in DeFrancis,1989, p.95). The Taiwanese
language,
____
which originates from
the Banlaam (Min-nan, Southern
Min ) language,
____
accordingly has its
unique Sino-writing in harnji (Han
) characters. These harnji
____
characters were borrowed
from the ancient northern
Haxn language to code
____
the pronunciations
of many southern languages, including the southern Min
____
language.
But the major problem of Taiwanese is that the Sino-Taiwanese
has
____
never been considered
as themainstream for writing and official use in Taiwan;
____
consequently, it gradually
has lost themany
harnji
characters uniquely used in
____
this language, although
even the usage of these characters has never been
____
unified.
On the other hand, people in today's Taiwan are no longer able to use
____
this writing tp wrote
Taiwanese as aform of written communication; on the
____
other hand, Sino-Taiwanese
had never been popularized because of the
____
historical and culturalbackground
of Taiwan.
____
____Before
the Japanese colonial period (1895-1945), literacy was generally low
____
in Taiwan. Most of
the people were illiterate, for only people from well-to-do
____
families were able
to go to private schools or to hire a tutor to learn to read and
____
write classical Chinese.
Poor people couldn't afford education, and women
____
were not allowed to
go to school at that time. Later, during the Japanese
____
colonial period, the
official language was the Japanese language, by which mass
____
education was offered.
After World War II, the "mainlanders" and their
____
descendants (who today
compose approximately 12-14% of the population in
____
Taiwan) who arrived
on Taiwan in 1949 have strongly promoted Mandarin as
____
the official language
(MacDonald, 1988, p. 13), by which education is offered
____
and media are dominated.
____
____It
is because of the massive immigration of mainlanders after 1949 that the
____
position of the official
language is so unusually strong for Taiwan, a
____
non-Mandarin-speaking
region (Norman, 1988, p.248). The mainland
____
population in Taiwan
was originally associated with either the Nationalist
____
government or with
the Nationalist army, and many of them had already
____
possessed a basic
working knowledge of the official language Mandarin when
____
they first arrived
in Taiwan (Norman, 1988, p.251).
____
Today, most Taiwanese people can fluently speak and write Mandarin in
____
any official occasion;
the adult literacy in Taiwan was 95% in 1985 (MacDonald,
____
1988, p. 14).
However, Taiwanese is still the major tongue of people's daily
____
communication underinformal
settings and in closer relations, despite the great
____
progress in promoting
the official language which has been made in the last
thirty
____
years (Norman, 1988,
p.248). But inmetropolitan areas, notably the capital
____
Taipei, a large number
of people under forty years of age, in the course
of
____
growing up and especially
as a result of their schooling, haveabandoned or
____
forgotten their non-standard
family dialects (including Taiwanese and other
____
dialects) acquired
in their infancy and have switched to the official language
____
Mandarin astheir sole
means of oral communication (Norman, 1988, p.251). In
____
some young familieschildren
have begun to learn Mandarin as their first
____
language, and in effect
these children become native speakers of this standard
____
language (Norman,
1988, p.251).
____
1.2-3
The Role of the Taiwanese Language in the Democratic Movements --- How
It Serves As a Symbol of Ethnic Consciousness
____
____Before
the 1986 democratic reform, public discussion and criticism about
____
the language policy
had long been a political taboo in Taiwan. The democratic
____
reform since 1986
in Taiwan has launched a more native-orientedideology
____
among the Taiwanese
people than before; this includes the struggle for civil
____
rights, the awareness
of environmental protection, the reform of native
____
Taiwanese culture,and
the equality of language distribution in media use.
____
These sense of consciousness
and the resulting actions consequently evoke
____
public concern about
the very medium of communication -- the long belittled
____
Taiwanese language,
which many reform-mindedpeople saw as a symbol of
____
native consciousness
and an emblem and fortress preservingTaiwanese culture.
____
____In
some cases of democratic movements, especially in the issue of
____
independency,the Taiwanese
language is viewed as a symbol of native ethnic
____
consciousness (Ross,
in Giles and Saint-Jacques, 1979, p. 10) in contrast
to the
____
Sino-centric ideology
imposed by the ruling authority and symbolized by
the
____
official language
Mandarin.
____
1.2-4
Ideographic Writing in Computerized Data ProcessingSystems
____
____ As
Mandarin Chinese is the official language in Taiwan, the writing based
____
on it accordingly
is the standard form of written communication. Chinese
____
typewriters, wordprocessors,
and especially computational systems have been
____
produced or developed
to deal with jobs associated with data processing
in
____
offices and families.
It is common, however,that the users of these data
____
processing systems
get both mentally and physically stressed (Unger,
1987, p.
____
129) with their jobs
done inefficiently. This is because of the complex and
____
time-consuming process
of inputting the large number of complex ideographic
____
Chinesecharacters.
____
____Generally,
there are three different ways commonly used in today's Taiwan
____
to input Chinese characters
into computers. ___One
is a word-structuring
____
package called "Tsang
Chieh ." To complete a text, the
operators using this
____
program construct
the Chinese
harnjicharacters by typing different parts of the
____
characters from a
special keyboard with small parts of characters. If the
user
____
doesn't know the ideographic
composure of a word, he or she has to interrupt
____
to look up the composure
of the word or just fail to complete the typing if
no
____
source of reference
is available.
____
____Another
way to input harnji characters is an extension of Chinese
____
dictionaries thatdivided
harnji characters into different families under different
____
radicals.
To input a single character, the user first has to know which radical
____
this character belongs
to. The biggest problem of this program is that very
few
____
people know the radicals
of every hamji
character, including those who are
____
mastering Chinese
literature and language. Most people know little about which
____
characters belong
to which radicals.
____
____The
most commonly used program in Chinese computational data
____
processing systems
in Taiwan needs a special keyboard with symbols for
____
phonetic notations
of Mandarin Chinese (in Mandarin the zhu`yi^nfu'ha`o
)
____
(Norman, 1988, p.259).
When typing a Chinese text on a computer using this
____
program, the user
has to type the phonetic combination of a particular word, then
____
press the "enter"
or "return" command on the keyboard. When finished, there is
____
a series of Chinese
hamji
characters
representing this phonetic combination
____
appearing at the bottom
of the screen with Arabic numerals indicating each
single
____
character.
What the user has to do is select the numeral indicating the right
____
character.
If the user cannot find the right character, he or she has to press the
____
"enter" or
"return" command again and again, till the right character appears.
____
After finishing allthese
steps, the processing of a single hamji
character is
____
completed and that
single character appears and located in the writer's
text on the
____
screen.
The major problem of this word program is that in Mandarin Chinese
____
there are too many
homophones sharing the same phonetic combination (Liim,
____
1992, p.23); this
takes the users much time and labor to complete data
processing
____
character by character.
Moreover, it also bothers those who are not able to
____
pronounce Mandarin
correctly.____
____
____The
three methods used in Chinese computerized data processing described
____
aboveare time-consuming,
and mentally and physically stress the users (Unger,
____
1987, p. 129).
Economically, on the other hand, computational data processing
____
costs more to output
information written in ideographic than in alphanumeric
____
form because of the
large numberof the ideographic characters and their graphic
____
complexity (Unger,
1987, p. 129). The extraexpense comes from a need for
a
____
high-resolution video
monitor or printer, extra memoryfor storing the
hamji
____
characters, longer
plotting times, fewer characters per page, or someother
____
hardware-related factors
(Unger, 1987, p. 129).
____
____This
thesis, therefore, explored the potential of the moderm literal Taiwanese,
____
a Latin
alphabetical writing system which can well convey both the sound and
____
sense of the Taiwanese
language. It is not an instruction of this writing system,
____
but an investigation
of why it is important for the Taiwanese people and their
____
culture, how it can
serve as an instrument of identity change, as well
as how it
____
can help people communicate
more conveniently and efficiently in an
____
increasingly technology-based
society.
____
1.3
The Significance of the Problem
____
____Language
is a primary tool of human communication; and the written form
____
of a particular
language is the most important medium to preserve this language,
____
both linguistically
and culturally. Therefore, the investigation of the potential
____
impact of theModern
Literal Taiwanese is significant in the study of human
____
communication.
This studyexplored how the ethnic identity of an
____
ethnolinguistic group
can be evoked, shaped, andeven manipulated through the
____
written form of the
mother tongue of that group, which haslong been depressed
____
under a special historical
and political setting; how this written form of the
____
mother tongue might
influence people's daily communication; and finally, how
____
this Latin alphabetical
writing system, being unencumbered with diacritical
____
marks, can beperfectly
processed through any computational data processing
____
systems just like
English or any other European languages.
____
1.3-1
The Significance of Language and Cultural Reform
____
____Under
the system of the Modern Literal Taiwanese, the spelling of each
____
single wordcorresponds
rather precisely to the pronunciation of this word as a
____
whole, and is no morethan
the simple combination of the phonetic
____
representation of
the constructing
harnji characters (Liim, 1988).
It is
____
alphabetical;
and no additional phonetic signs is used in this system
(See
____
Appendix 1).
For example, hoesoaan-ym,
the circling-around vowels uniquein
____
Taiwanese, are represented
in the forms as "aa," "ii," "uu," "ee," "oo," "oo,"
____
"mm," and "ngg."
This method of word spelling enables people to learn the
____
spoken Taiwanese by
memorizing words by spelling, and to write sentences
____
using an ordinary
typewriter or a word processor (Liim, 1988).
____
____From
the point of view of reforming the native language and culture, this
____
writing system is
potentially significant to the Taiwanese people for the following
____
reasons:
____
____*
First, scince Taiwanese is quite different from Mandarin in pronunciation,
____
____literalusage,
and grammatical syntax --- actually, in the linguistic terms,
the
____
____two
languages belong to different families --- this writing system
will
____
____provide
the native speakers of Taiwanese with a channel to
emancipate their
____
____inner
feelings and thoughts withoutthe distortion and difficulty in using the
____
____official
Chinese writing, which is grammatically syntaxed and
literally
____
____composed
in Mandarin.
____
____*
Second, with this writing system, folk ballads and anecdotes transmitted
____
____orally
can be effectively preserved with their original style and emphasis.
____
____On
the other hand, with literature and a formal written
form, the Taiwanese
____
____language
can be better preserved without the distortion and
disorganization
____
____caused
by long-termmisuse. In this regard both the Taiwanese
language
____
____itself
and the literature or arts associated with this language
can be preserved
____
____by
its written form both linguistically and culturally.
____
1.3-2
The Significance of the Impact on Ethnic Identity
____
____Since
the Taiwanese language, as has been discussed formerly, plays the role
____
as a symbol
of ethnic consciousness (Ross, in Giles and Saint-Jacques, 1979, p.
____
10) in thedemocratic
movements in Taiwan, accordingly, a writing system which
____
can well serve as
a medium of written communication of the language
will play a
____
part as the visible
symbol of the ethnic consciousness of the Taiwanese
people.
____
Also, it may socio-culturally
and psychologically build a collective identity
____
among the Taiwanese
people within the contextof native culture in terms of the
____
cultural significance
of writing in preserving a language.
____
____Language,
together with ethnicity, are basic elements of the identity
____
and individuality
of a human being (Saint-Jacques and Giles, 1979). Moreover,
____
since languageis a
part of the codified culture (Schramm and Porter, 1982, p.81)
____
and the unifying factorof
a particular culture (Saint-Jacques and Giles, 1979),
____
and whereas writing
codes language, this modern literal Taiwanese might
____
spontaneously awaken
a more native-oriented identity among the Taiwanese
____
people.
This spontaneous awareness might happenwhen the Taiwanese people
____
are acculturated under
the literal orientation of the written Taiwanese language.
____
This is because written
language is not only a derivative symbolsystem enjoying
____
only a parasitic status
with respect to oral language (Scinto, 1986, p. 1) but also
____
a culturally organized
function or system subject to learning and development
____
(Scinto,1986, p-77).
Also, language itself is a dynamic force in the unfolding
____
progression of group
interaction and identity formation (Ross, in Giles and
____
Saint-Jacques, 1979,
p.ll); it isimportant as a symbol of an underlying image of
____
group purpose and
identity, and in this regard, it is the most powerful
single
____
symbol of ethnicity
because it serves as a shorthandfor all that makes a group
____
special and unique
(Ross, in Giles and Saint-Jacques, 1979,P.9).
____
1.3-3
The Significance of Efficient Computerized Data Communications
____
____The
use of data communications through computers is expected to
____
increase tremendously
in the future (Liim, 1990a, p.5). Actually, the past decade
____
has witnessed aboom
in computer data communications, which enables
____
computers and their
operators to "talk" in highly efficient networks (Duffy,
1992,
____
p. 170).
The highly efficient datacommunications through computers requires
____
efficient input, which
combines the speed and accuracy of data input with the
____
minimum of physical
and mental stress of users on man/machine interface, and
____
output, which seeks
minimum hardware costs (Ungjfer, 1987,p. 129). Those
____
languages with a large
number of ideographic characters such as Chinese and
____
Japanese, however
are not well suited for efficient and convenient input and
____
output of dataprocessing
owing to the complex and large number of ideographic
____
characters (Unger,1987,
p.64). Therefore, in order to achieve efficient data
____
communication, in
Japan Romaji(the Romanized writing) and kana
have been
____
widely used in data
communication systems instead of
kanji
(this term is
____
equivalent to hamji
characters)
(Unger, 1987, p. 19). China has also been
____
promoting writing
reforms such as alphabetization and simplification of
____
characters in Mandarin
Chinese since the early twentieth century (Norman, 1988,
____
p.262).
However, in terms of alphabetization of characters, there is an
____
unsolvable problem
in the Mandarin language itself: the large
number of
____
homophones sharing
the same spellings,which has caused ambiguieties among
____
characters for a particular
pronunciation (Liim,1990a, p.58; andHsu, in VIST,
____
1991, p. 195).
On the other hand, for thousands of years Taiwanese has
____
primarily served as
an oral language; therefore, the articulation
and
____
pronunciation of this
language is very slightlydistinguished by the speakers to
____
avoid miscommunication
(Liim, 1990a, p.4). As a result,there are very few
____
homophones in this
language and, therefore, the phonetic ambiguieties which
____
Mandarin has suffered
in data processing can be avoided (Liim, 1990a, p.4,
____
p.58). Accordingly,
this alphabetical writing system is potentially superior to
____
the traditional ideographic
harnji
characters
in terms of efficiency and economy
____
in data processing,
which is crucial in today's technology-based society and the
____
arena ofinternational
competition. It can be efficiently processed through
____
computers, word processors,
or just ordinary typewriters like English or other
____
European languages
and can save time and labor. Moreover,
the additional
____
demands on hardware
to code and outputharnji
characters will be unnecessary.
____
1.3-4
The Significance of Efficient Language Learning and Functional Literacy
____
____As
spelling makes the learning of written language easier and therefore
____
enables
literacy more funcionary applied than memorizing the graphic structures
____
of
ideographic characters (Liim, 1990a, p4). the Modern Literal Taiwanese
is
____
expected
to help Taiwanese learn the writing of their native language efficiently.
____
Also.
it will provided anyone who wants to learn this language with a reliable
____
and
efficient sourse of learning.
________
____The
impact of the Modern Literal Taiwanese on the Taiwanese people is
____
potentially
significant in both communication and socio-cultural levels.
In terms
____
of
communication, on the one hand, the writing system will enable the native
____
speakers
of Taiwanese to express their inner thoughts and feelings and makes the
____
learning
of written Taiwanese efficient and convenient. On the other
hand, as
____
computers
and technology will be used tremendously in any work place, family,
____
business,
and industry in the future (Liim, 1990a, p.5), it is, therefore,
crucial for
____
any society to have
efficient and economical data processing systems to be
____
competent in international
competition.
____
____And
socio-culturally, it will keep the Taiwanese language itself
____
from disorganization
and distortion. It will also preserve the folk literature,
____
which is culturally
important, from oblivion. Lastly, it might serve as a medium
____
of written communication
for the Taiwanese language, which, politically, is
a
____
symbol of ethnic consciousness
(Ross, inGiles and Saint-Jacques, 1979, p. 10) in
____
many Taiwanese democratic
movements. InTaiwan today more and more
____
people are looking
forward to a more democratic political environment with a
____
more native Taiwan-oriented
ideology; while the issue of independency has been
____
highly debatable and
controversial, it is interesting to investigate how and why
____
this writing system
might impact the ethnic identity among the Taiwanese people.
____